Trying to save some cash this year I have decided not to replace my old winter riding boots (now rotten) and try over-shoes instead. I've not had good experiences in the past with overshoes. They either seem to be impossible to put on quickly, or fall off, or flap.
I decided to go for some budget ones and see how I got on without spending too much.
I've now had two rides in freezing temperatures using the SPEG over-shoes and they seem to work well. They are easy to pull on and fasten simply with a huge Velcro tab at the back, covered in reflective tape, though I've not tried them in the rain or snow yet !
SPEG 'Teksion' Tri-Layer Neoprene Overshoes
At only £15.00 I think I might get another pair (I even get cold feet in the garage on the turbo)!
